KeyStage

Key Stage 3 English · Writing

KS3 drafting, editing and proofreading: a guide for parents

In Years 7 to 9, pupils are taught to treat writing as a process rather than a one-go task: plan it, draft it, edit it for meaning and style, then proofread it for accuracy. Each stage has a different job, and the thread running through all of them is audience and purpose. The habit matters because it separates writing that merely fills the page from writing that works on the person reading it, and it carries straight into GCSE.

Drafting, editing and proofreading, explained

Planning, drafting, editing and proofreading are four different jobs, and at Key Stage 3 teachers try to get pupils to keep them apart. Planning decides what to say, in what order and for whom. Drafting gets a first version down. Editing changes the content, order and wording. Proofreading comes last and catches slips in spelling, punctuation and grammar. A pupil who tries to do all four at once, fixing a comma while still deciding what the argument is, usually does each of them badly.

The statutory curriculum starts with audience and purpose. Before and during drafting, pupils are asked who will read the piece and what it is meant to do: persuade a headteacher, help Year 6 pupils on a visit day, entertain a competition judge or explain an idea to a teacher. The same facts need a different tone, vocabulary and level of detail for each. Many teachers have pupils write the audience and purpose at the top of the plan and check back against them at every stage.

Editing is where most of the improvement happens, and it is more than tidying. Pupils amend vocabulary by swapping vague words such as “nice”, “bad” or “got” for precise ones. They amend grammar by varying sentence length, changing how sentences open and combining short sentences. They amend structure by reordering paragraphs, tightening an opening and adding links so that each sentence follows from the last. That is what teachers mean by coherence. Lessons often model this on the board with a weak paragraph, then pupils redraft their own work, sometimes in a different colour of pen so the changes show.

Proofreading is the final check on accuracy. Pupils are expected to apply the spelling patterns and rules taught in primary school: prefixes and suffixes, doubled consonants, words with silent letters, endings such as -able and -ible, and homophones like “their”, “there” and “they’re”. At this stage the emphasis is on pupils noticing and fixing their own errors. Useful strategies include reading aloud, reading one sentence at a time from the end of the piece backwards, and checking for one type of error per pass.

GCSE writing is assessed on content and organisation as well as on technical accuracy, and it is done under timed conditions with no chance for a full second draft. The Key Stage 3 habit shrinks to a short plan at the start and a few minutes of checking at the end. Pupils who have practised the full process at length find the short version much easier.

Words your child will hear

Audience
The person or group who will read or hear the writing, such as a headteacher, a younger pupil or a competition judge.
Purpose
What the writing is meant to do: to inform, explain, persuade, describe, entertain or argue.
Draft
A first full version of a piece of writing, expected to be changed.
Redraft
A new version written after editing, with ideas, order or wording improved.
Coherence
How well a piece holds together, so each sentence and paragraph follows clearly from the one before.
Proofread
Read carefully to find and correct slips in spelling, punctuation and grammar before finishing.
Homophone
A word that sounds like another but has a different meaning and spelling, such as “knew” and “new”.

What the National Curriculum says

In Key Stage 3, pupils should be taught to:

  • Plan, draft, edit and proof-read through considering how their writing reflects the audiences and purposes for which it was intended
  • Plan, draft, edit and proof-read through amending the vocabulary, grammar and structure of their writing to improve its coherence and overall effectiveness
  • Plan, draft, edit and proof-read through paying attention to accurate grammar, punctuation and spelling, applying the spelling patterns and rules set out in English Appendix 1 to the key stage 1 and 2 programmes of study

Objectives from the National Curriculum in England, © Crown copyright, used under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

A worked example: from first draft to finished paragraph

A Year 8 pupil is writing to the headteacher to argue that lunchtimes need changing. Their first draft is: “Our school canteen is really bad. The food is cold and there is never enough. Loads of people think its bad. We should do something about it.” Improve it step by step.

  1. Check audience and purpose. The reader is a headteacher and the aim is to persuade, so the tone should be polite and formal, with reasons and a clear request. “Really bad” and “loads of people” are too vague and too casual.
  2. Edit the content first. Replace opinions with specific detail: hot meals arrive lukewarm, and the queue is so long that pupils at the back have only ten minutes left to eat. Add what the pupil wants to happen: two practical changes.
  3. Edit the sentences and structure. Open with the problem, give the evidence, then make the request. Combine two short sentences and vary the openings. The redraft reads: “Lunchtime in the canteen needs urgent attention. Hot meals are often served lukewarm, and the queue is so long that pupils at the back of it have only ten minutes left to eat. I would like to propose two changes: staggered lunch breaks and a second serving counter.”
  4. Proofread last, reading aloud and checking one thing at a time. An early version of the final sentence read “Both changes would shorten the pupils queue”, and the check for apostrophes shows it needs a possessive: “the pupils’ queue”. The same check catches “its” for “it’s” in the original draft, although that sentence has since been cut. A separate spelling pass, read slowly, picks out words that are easy to get wrong, such as “staggered” and “propose”.

“Lunchtime in the canteen needs urgent attention. Hot meals are often served lukewarm, and the queue is so long that pupils at the back of it have only ten minutes left to eat. I would like to propose two changes: staggered lunch breaks and a second serving counter. Both would shorten the pupils’ queue and give everyone a fair chance of a hot meal.”

Common mistakes and how to help

“Editing” just means correcting spelling and punctuation

Marked work in earlier years often highlights small errors, so pupils come to think improving writing means fixing mistakes. That is proofreading, which comes last.

What helps: Ask for one change to the ideas before any check of the spelling: something to cut, something to add or something to move. Treat the spelling pass as a separate, final job.

Longer, grander words always make writing better

Pupils are told to improve their vocabulary and reach for the thesaurus, which can leave a sentence sounding stiff or slightly wrong.

What helps: Look for the most precise word, not the most impressive one. Reading a sentence aloud is a good test: if it sounds like nobody would say it, try again.

Planning is a waste of time for a short piece

Confident writers feel that a plan slows them down, and starting to write feels like progress.

What helps: A plan can be four bullet points and take two minutes. Point out that it is exactly the skill needed in a timed GCSE exam, where there is no room to restructure later.

“The spell-checker will catch everything”

Spell-checkers flag misspelt words, but a correctly spelt wrong word such as “there” for “their” passes without comment, and automatic corrections can introduce new mistakes.

What helps: Read the piece aloud or on paper. Keep a short list of the three errors your child makes most often and check for those specifically.

How to help at home

  • Ask who it is for first. When your child is about to write, ask “Who will read this and what do you want them to do or feel?” The answer shapes the tone and the detail, and it is the question teachers want asked.
  • Be the reader, not the marker. Ask to hear a piece read aloud and say only where you got lost or stumbled. Pupils often hear their own mistakes as they read, which is more effective than being told them.
  • Leave it overnight. Where there is no deadline, suggest drafting one day and editing the next. Fresh eyes find far more than tired ones, and this is a habit worth building.
  • Write for a real reader. A polite complaint to a company, a message to a relative or a review of a book all have real audiences and a clear purpose. Writing that will actually be sent gets more care than writing that will only be marked.
  • Keep a personal error list. Help your child note the three mistakes they repeat most, perhaps apostrophes, “their/there” or run-on sentences. Checking only for those during a final read is quicker and more reliable than a vague check for everything.

Related topics

Builds on

Leads on to

More on writing

Everything in Key Stage 3 English

Updated .